Fork & Embers Recipe

Authentic Kentucky Burgoo Recipe

October 25, 2026 Fork & Embers Jump to recipe
Authentic Kentucky Burgoo Recipe

The Story

When the weather starts cooling off, it's hard to beat a big pot of homemade stew. And here in Kentucky, we've got one that's been feeding hungry crowds for generations.

Kentucky burgoo is a thick, hearty Southern stew made with multiple meats, plenty of vegetables, and a rich broth that's simmered until everything comes together.

For this recipe, I'm using beef chuck roast, lamb shoulder, and chicken thighs, along with potatoes, tomatoes, cabbage, corn, lima beans, and okra. But I'm also putting my own barbecue spin on this old-fashioned Kentucky favorite by smoking the meats before they go into the Dutch oven.

It's rich, filling, and exactly the kind of comfort food you want on a cold fall evening. And if you don't own a smoker, don't worry. You can make a fantastic burgoo right on your stovetop.

What Is Kentucky Burgoo?

Kentucky burgoo is a traditional Southern stew made with a combination of meats and vegetables that are slowly cooked together until everything becomes thick, tender, and full of flavor.

Unlike a typical beef stew, burgoo usually features multiple kinds of meat. Beef, chicken, lamb, mutton, and pork have all appeared in Kentucky burgoo recipes, along with the occasional wild game.

The vegetables are just as varied. Potatoes, corn, tomatoes, cabbage, lima beans, carrots, and okra are common additions, although you'll find plenty of recipes that leave some of those out.

The real defining characteristic is how everything comes together during a long, slow simmer.

The meat becomes tender enough to pull apart, the vegetables soften, and the broth thickens into something much heartier than an ordinary vegetable soup.

Some people like their burgoo a little soupy. Others want it thick enough that a spoon practically stands up in the bowl.

Personally, I lean toward the thicker stuff.

What Meat Goes in Traditional Kentucky Burgoo?

Ask five Kentuckians what meat belongs in burgoo, and there's a good chance you'll get five different answers.

Historically, burgoo was made with whatever meats were available. Beef, chicken, pork, lamb, and mutton have all been used, and some older recipes even included squirrel, rabbit, and other wild game.

And no, you don't need to go hunting squirrels to make an authentic pot of burgoo.

For my version, I'm sticking with three meats that work particularly well together.

Beef chuck roast brings a deep, beefy flavor and enough connective tissue to become incredibly tender during the long simmer.

Lamb shoulder adds a rich, slightly distinctive flavor that separates this from your everyday beef-and-vegetable stew.

Chicken thighs add another layer of flavor and stay moist and tender when cooked properly.

One thing worth pointing out is that lamb and mutton aren't the same thing. Lamb comes from younger sheep, while mutton comes from mature sheep and generally has a stronger, more pronounced flavor.

Mutton is particularly important to the barbecue and burgoo traditions around Owensboro in western Kentucky. If you can find it, you can substitute it for the lamb shoulder in this recipe.

But if all you've got access to is beef and chicken, you can still make a good burgoo. The dish has always been flexible.

Why Smoke the Meat Before Making Burgoo?

Traditionally, Kentucky burgoo was cooked in enormous iron kettles over wood fires. That doesn't necessarily mean the meat was smoked before it went into the stew.

That's my addition.

Before building the burgoo, I give the beef, lamb, and chicken some time on the smoker over oak or hickory.

The idea isn't to completely cook the beef or lamb on the smoker. We're primarily looking to develop a flavorful exterior, pick up some wood smoke, and build another layer of flavor before the meat goes into the pot.

Once everything starts simmering together, that smoky flavor makes its way into the broth and vegetables.

It's subtle enough that the finished dish still tastes like Kentucky burgoo, but you get an additional depth that you wouldn't have otherwise.

Can You Make Kentucky Burgoo Without a Smoker?

Absolutely.

If you don't have a smoker, you can brown the meats in a Dutch oven or heavy skillet before adding them to the stew.

That browning develops a flavorful crust through the Maillard reaction, creating the kind of rich, savory flavors that help build a good stew.

You won't get the same wood-smoked flavor, but you'll still end up with a delicious burgoo.

And if you want a more traditional approach, cooking the entire dish in a heavy pot over a wood fire is another option.

Why a Dutch Oven Works So Well for Burgoo

There aren't many pieces of cookware better suited to a long, slow stew than a heavy Dutch oven.

The thick walls retain heat, helping the burgoo maintain a gentle, consistent simmer for several hours.

That matters because we're working with tougher cuts like chuck roast and lamb shoulder. These meats need time for their connective tissue to break down and become tender.

The Dutch oven also allows you to build flavor in stages.

You can sauté the vegetables, cook down the tomatoes, add the meats and stock, and finish the entire dish in the same pot.

And because burgoo gets thicker as it cooks, having a heavy-bottomed pot helps reduce the risk of scorching, although you'll still want to stir it regularly.

Just make sure your Dutch oven is large enough. Burgoo contains quite a bit of meat and vegetables, and you'll need room to stir everything without making a mess.

How Thick Should Kentucky Burgoo Be?

There's no universally accepted thickness for Kentucky burgoo, but it should generally be heartier than a typical vegetable soup.

In some traditional versions, the meat is shredded so finely and the vegetables are cooked so long that everything practically becomes one thick mixture.

Other versions leave more recognizable pieces of meat and vegetables.

I like a little texture in mine, but I still want the broth thick enough to coat everything.

The good news is that you don't need flour or cornstarch to get there.

As the russet potatoes cook, they release starch into the broth. You can also mash a few of the softened potatoes against the side of the Dutch oven to naturally thicken the stew.

If the burgoo is still too thin, remove the lid and let it simmer until some of the liquid evaporates.

If it gets too thick, stir in a little additional hot stock or water.

And don't forget that burgoo will generally thicken as it cools.

What's the Difference Between Burgoo and Brunswick Stew?

Kentucky burgoo and Brunswick stew have a lot in common.

Both are hearty Southern stews traditionally made with meat, vegetables, and a long cooking process. Both have a history of being prepared in large quantities for community gatherings.

The main differences come down to their regional traditions and the meats commonly used.

Kentucky burgoo is especially associated with beef, chicken, lamb, and mutton, although plenty of other combinations exist.

Brunswick stew, which is closely associated with Virginia and Georgia, commonly uses chicken, pork, and sometimes wild game.

Ingredients like tomatoes, corn, potatoes, and lima beans can appear in both, depending on who's cooking.

There's enough overlap that the two dishes can look pretty similar, but each has its own history and regional identity.

And if you ask somebody from Kentucky which one is better, I can probably guess the answer.

A Little History Behind Kentucky Burgoo

Burgoo has been part of Kentucky food culture for generations, with the state's own version developing during the nineteenth century.

Back then, burgoo was particularly useful for feeding large crowds at livestock sales, political gatherings, horse-racing events, and community celebrations.

Cooks would prepare enormous iron kettles over wood fires, sometimes spending most of a day stirring meat and vegetables into a thick stew.

A few of those cooks became famous.

James T. Looney, a Lexington cook nicknamed the "Burgoo King," was so well known that a racehorse was named in his honor. That horse went on to win the 1932 Kentucky Derby and Preakness Stakes.

Over in western Kentucky, burgoo became closely connected to Owensboro's mutton barbecue tradition and the large community picnics that helped preserve it.

Today, the dish remains one of Kentucky's recognizable regional foods, with different restaurants, families, and communities maintaining their own versions.

And that's what I like about burgoo. It's never really belonged to one person or one particular recipe.

Is Burgoo Good for Fall Dinners and Kentucky Derby Parties?

Burgoo is one of those dishes that makes just as much sense at a fall family dinner as it does at a large Kentucky gathering.

For fall and winter, you've got a rich, comforting meal that's packed with meat and vegetables. Everything cooks together in one pot, and leftovers reheat beautifully.

It's also a natural fit for Kentucky Derby parties, especially if you're putting together a menu featuring traditional Kentucky foods.

And because burgoo can be made ahead of time, you don't have to spend the entire gathering standing over a stove.

Historically, this dish was made to feed crowds, so scaling the recipe up for a family reunion, tailgate, or backyard party is very much in keeping with the tradition.

What to Serve With Kentucky Burgoo

Burgoo is already a substantial meal, so you don't need much to go alongside it.

But if I'm making a big pot, there are a few things I'd consider serving with it.

  • Southern cornbread: Probably my favorite option. A good piece of cornbread is perfect for soaking up the thick, flavorful broth.

  • Buttermilk biscuits: Soft, buttery biscuits work just as well, especially when they're fresh from the oven.

  • Saltine crackers: Sometimes the simplest option is the best.

  • Pickled vegetables: Something tangy helps cut through the richness of the meat.

  • Hot sauce: A few dashes are great if you prefer a little more heat.

If you're serving burgoo as part of a larger barbecue spread, it also makes a fantastic side dish alongside smoked meats.

Can You Make Kentucky Burgoo Ahead of Time?

Absolutely. In fact, burgoo is one of those dishes that often tastes even better the next day.

After sitting in the refrigerator overnight, the flavors continue to mingle, and the broth generally becomes thicker.

Let the finished burgoo cool quickly by dividing it into smaller, shallow containers, then refrigerate within two hours.

It will keep in the refrigerator for 3–4 days or in the freezer for approximately 2–3 months for best quality.

When reheating, add a splash of stock or water if the stew has become too thick. Heat it thoroughly to 165°F before serving.

Burgoo is also a great candidate for freezing in individual portions, giving you an easy homemade meal whenever you want one.

Making Kentucky Burgoo Your Own

If there's one thing I've learned looking into the history of Kentucky burgoo, it's that there really isn't one definitive recipe.

Some cooks use mutton. Others prefer beef and chicken. Some add okra, some leave it out, and some swear the stew needs to cook practically all day.

For this version, we're sticking with the things that have made Kentucky burgoo popular for generations: multiple meats, plenty of vegetables, and a long, slow cooking process.

The smoked meat is simply my own contribution to the tradition.

And while my Dutch oven is a hell of a lot smaller than the giant kettles those old burgoo cooks were working with, the idea is the same.

Make a big pot of something delicious, let it cook until everything comes together, and share it with somebody.

You'll find the full Kentucky burgoo recipe, ingredients, and step-by-step cooking instructions below.

Affiliate disclosure: Some links in this article may be affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend gear I actually use.

star

Affiliate picks

For this cook

Tools, ingredients, and products worth grabbing for this recipe. Links may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Portable Induction Burner

Portable Induction Burner

I love this because it works quickly to heat things and I don't have to crowd my stove when having large dinners.

Cast Iron Dutch Oven

Cast Iron Dutch Oven

Great for long cooks and the thick cast iron allows for amazing heat retention. This is my go to pan when cooking stews, soups, etc.

Prep Cups
Nice-to-Have

Prep Cups

Small containers for measuring ingredients, organizing prep, and storing leftovers.

These make big cooks feel way less chaotic. You can measure everything out ahead of time and have it ready to go before the fire is hot.

Nitrile Gloves
Nice-to-Have

Nitrile Gloves

Disposable gloves for cleaner prep, seasoning, trimming, and handling meat.

When I’m outside cooking and do not have a sink right beside me, gloves are my best friend. They keep prep cleaner and make it easier to move between raw meat, seasoning, and the grill.

Torch
Nice-to-Have

Torch

A torch for lighting fires quickly and finishing crispy spots on food.

It is not completely necessary, but it makes lighting things much easier than dealing with a lighter. It is also great when one little spot on your food needs extra heat.

Fire Resistant Gloves
Must-Have

Fire Resistant Gloves

Heat-resistant gloves that protect your hands and arms when working over hot fire.

These are one of those things you wish you bought before you burn your arm reaching across a hot grill. I like gloves that come farther up the arm so you get more protection.

Tumbleweed Firestarters
Must-Have

Tumbleweed Firestarters

Simple fire starters that work perfectly under a charcoal chimney.

They are easy, reliable, and pair perfectly with a chimney. You can use torn-up charcoal bag pieces, but those tend to go out on me before the charcoal gets going.

Charcoal Chimney
Must-Have

Charcoal Chimney

The easiest way to light charcoal cleanly without using lighter fluid.

Starting charcoal can be a headache, and a chimney makes it simple, repeatable, and cleaner tasting. Please do not use lighter fluid unless you want your food tasting like a gas station parking lot.

0 comments

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

    1 out of ...